How and Where to Sell Your Gold Coins

Many people have gold coins that they plan to sell but don’t know where to start. Are you confused about how and where to sell your gold coins for cash? If you’re worried about being scammed or confused by the numerous options, you’ve come to the right place.

The process of selling gold coins is pretty simple, but you need to consider several factors, such as understanding the value of your coin, choosing a reputable dealer, and the tax implications of selling your coins. Continue reading to learn how and where to sell your gold coins successfully.

How to Get the Best Price for Your Gold Coins

Everyone wants to get the best possible deal from their investment, and gold coins are no exception. By implementing the following tips, you’ll obtain the best price for your coins:

Find Out the Current Price of Gold

The first step is to check out the current market price of gold coins. The precious metals market fluctuates, and it is ideal to sell while the prices are higher. Find out what the spot price of gold is to get a better idea of its value. The spot price is the current price being sold on the date and time of a transaction, although buyers cannot buy gold at the specific spot price.

Understand the Value of Your Coin

coins in a red background

You shouldn’t put your coins up for sale until you know what they are worth. Since various factors can affect the value of gold coins, it’s essential to consider the following: weight, condition, age, and size. For example, you could have a rare coin with a high value that an inexperienced collector wouldn’t recognize.

You should have your coins appraised before putting them up for sale; knowing the estimated value will help you avoid getting ripped off.

Take Good Care of Your Coins

Like your house, gold coins are physical assets, and their condition will affect their price. Keep your coins safe and handle them with care. The 24-carat coins are incredibly delicate and prone to scratching, which will affect their sale price.

If your coins are dirty, wash them in warm soapy water. Consider investing in plastic coin capsules to house your coins, so you can handle them without worrying about degrading their condition.

Only Work with a Reputable Dealer

Many individuals and companies advertise that they will give you an incredible price for your coins. It’s crucial to make sure you’re dealing with a reputable buyer who strictly follows the industry’s guidelines.

Many inexperienced investors make the mistake of taking their coins to dishonest dealers, such as pawn shops. Working with an established precious metals dealer is the safest way to ensure you get the best price for your coins.

Notify Your Dealer Well in Advance

You can sell your coins whenever you want, but giving your dealer at least a few weeks’ notice can help them connect you with a better buyer. An experienced gold broker can work with you to get a higher price for your coins since they usually have an extensive network of investors, and connecting buyers and sellers can improve value for both parties. Using a dealer instead of simply putting your coins up for sale in the wholesale market will increase your chances of fetching a fair price for your gold coins.

Where to Sell Your Gold Coins

Do you have gold coins but have no idea where to sell them? Here are some of the best online and offline options for you:

Local Gold Bullion Dealers

Larger cities usually have several reputable gold bullion dealers that also buy and sell gold coins. Make sure your prospective local dealer is a member of a trusted organization such as Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) or Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), and avoid potentially unscrupulous dealers such as pawn shops.

Direct Sales to Collectors

Collectors have a deep understanding of the value of coins and are especially interested in rare coins. If you have a rare coin, you can expect a collector to pay a top dollar to get it in their possession.

Coin Shows and Expos

people in a coin event

Many coin and bullion shows and expos take place every year, especially in major cities. They can give you valuable information on where to sell your coins at the best prices and allow you to compare your coins with others on the market.

Rain Coin Auctions

One of the best places to find coin collectors is at rare coin auctions. Coin prices can rise dramatically, up to thousands or millions of dollars per piece, thanks to stiff competition at such events. If you’re looking to sell your rare coins, rare coin auctions would be a good place to start.


eBay is another excellent place to sell your gold coins, especially if you prefer online trading, but be aware of inexperienced buyers. Also, keep in mind seller fees may also eat into your profits.

Online Gold Bullion Dealers

You can find many established gold bullion buyers online, usually offering a fixed, exact price per unit for specific gold coins such as Buffalo gold coins and American Eagle gold coins.

Online gold bullion dealers often have low operating expenses, allowing them to offer competitive prices for gold coins. Once you sell your coins, you’ll need to ship them with a delivery service that provides insurance and tracking.

How to Find a Reputable Coin Dealer

The market is flooded with scammers and fraudulent dealers, so it’s essential to be cautious and use good judgment. Here are some reliable ways to find a legitimate buyer for your gold coins.

Consider the Experience

It’s best to work with a dealer who is a coin expert, especially one with experience in the specific type of coin you’re selling. Check whether your prospective coin buyer is a member of reputable coin organizations such as the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG) or American Numismatic Association (ANA). PNG only accepts individual members that have been in the business for at least five years.

How Long Have They Been in Business?

A coin dealer who has been in the business for several years has endured the market’s up and downs and is more likely to stay in business for the foreseeable future. Try to work with a company with an established track record and quality reviews.

Check for Real Assets

A coin dealer should have tangible assets, indicating they will be in the business for the foreseeable future. A shop full of authentic coins and various collectibles shows they’re a financially stable entity.  Just make sure the dealer owns the collectibles and is not holding them on consignment.

What Do the Dealer’s Peers Say?

An excellent way to determine whether your prospective buyer is reputable is to assess their reputation among other dealers. Coin dealers often get a bad reputation among their peers if they engage in unethical and dishonest practices. You might also want to ask other coin collectors about their experience with a particular dealer to learn more about their reputation.

What Happens if You Get Ripped Off?

PNG requires its coin dealer members to commit to binding arbitration to resolve disputes. This commitment is a crucial consideration if you’re investing in expensive coins to save you the stress and heartache of dealing with dubious dealers.

Tax Implications of Selling Your Gold Coins

calculating coin tax using a calculator and a laptop

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) considers any profits you gain from selling your precious metal assets as taxable and subject to capital gains tax. In general, capital gains refer to any profits resulting from the sale of an investment or property.

For precious metals, capital gains occur when a particular bullion piece or coin appreciates after the initial purchase, and then you sell it at a higher price. You will need to pay either a short-term or long-term capital gains tax on such profits, depending on how long you held the asset before selling.

When you sell a reportable quantity of specific coins, your dealer should file Form 1099-B with the IRS, which enlists losses or gains for specific consumer transactions. If you don’t follow tax reporting guidelines, the IRS may issue monetary fines or criminal charges against you and the coin dealer.

When you know the current market price for gold, understand the value of your coins, and find a reputable dealer that can offer a fair deal, you can quickly sell your coins for the best price.

Want to Invest in Gold? The Gold Experts at Oxford Gold Group Can Help You Today — Give Us a Call!

Investing in precious metals is a complex process that requires knowledge and experience. If you’re looking to invest in gold for savings or retirement purposes, you can get valuable information and expert advice at Oxford Gold Group. Our trusted team of gold experts will take you through every step to ensure you make the best investment decisions. Call us at (833) 600-GOLD (4653) or visit our Contact Page for more information!

Related Post


Learn How A Precious Metals IRA Can Secure Your Retirement

The precious metals market may seem intimidating, but it’s not as it seems. Our team has compiled a summary of our tips and information into a free guide so you can learn how to begin securing your future.


We Will Guide You Every Step Of The Way

Schedule a Call
Learn Why Everyone Should Own Real Gold & SilverRequest Your Free Step-By-Step Investment Guide

"*" indicates required fields

I'm interested in (please select all that apply):
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Inside this Free Investment Guide

  • How a Gold IRA Gives You Full Control.
  • How You Can Grow Your Retirement.
  • How to Open a Gold IRA Tax & Penalty Free.


By clicking the button above, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service and authorize Oxford Gold or someone acting on its behalf to contact you by text message, ringless voicemail, or on a recorded line at any telephone or mobile number you provide using automated telephone technology, including auto-dialers, for marketing purposes. No purchase required. Message and data rates may apply. You also agree to receive e-mail marketing from Oxford Gold, our affiliated companies, and third-party advertisers. To opt-out at any time click here or reply STOP to opt-out of text messages.